COVID-19 Business Interruption
Claims Court Case Decision
Lisa Carter - Director, Clear Insurance
On Wednesday 18 November the NSW Court of Appeal handed down a unanimous decision in a case launched by the Insurance Council of Australia
concerning the application of Business Interruption (BI) claims related to two test cases, where business operations were affected by
COVID-19 and their policy coverage denied.
The Court ruled that COVID-19 is not a disease “declared to be a quarantinable disease under the Quarantine Act 1908 and subsequent
amendments … and accordingly, was not excluded from the disease benefit clauses”.
This ruling means that policies containing an exclusion that referenced the Quarantine Act could not limit or exclude otherwise valid
claims. As such, policies that only included reference to this specific Act should now allow claims to proceed.
While this decision is a welcome one for policyholders as it removes a major hurdle to proceeding with claims, there are some additional
considerations that must be taken into account which include:
- The Court’s decision may be appealed and Insurers have up to 28 days to make such application to the High Court;
- Policies also contain other triggers that need to be met as to determine a valid claim. These include the location and/or proximity of a
business premises to an outbreak of COVID-19;
- BI claims are subject to adjustment to determine if turnover has reduced and/or business expense savings have been made, i.e. there needs
to be quantifiable loss;
- The calculation of the above point - considering both Federal and State Government incentives - to boost cashflow and keep as many
businesses operating as possible.
As each claims matter will be specific to your individual circumstances, we recommend that you contact your appointed insurance and risk
adviser to discuss your policy coverage details and next steps in the claims process.
If you have not already done so and believe your business has been affected by COVID-19 matters, we recommend that you lodge a claim as soon
as possible to ensure your intention to claim is acknowledged by your Insurer.
We welcome any queries in relation to this matter.
Lisa Carter Director QPIB
Ph: 0466 036 589
Jen Bettridge – Account Manager
Ph: 0405 219 861
Clear Insurance Pty Ltd is a Corporate Authorised Representative and Platinum Practice of Insurance Advisernet Australia Pty Ltd. CAR No.
465935. Australian Financial Service License Number: 240549. This information is of a general nature only and neither represents nor is
intended to be personal advice on any particular matter. Clear Insurance Pty ltd strongly suggests that no person should act specifically on
the basis of the information in this document, but should obtain appropriate professional advice based on their own personal circumstances.